First Presbyterian Church of Winchester

Serving Christ and Neighbor in Winchester and Beyond since 1800

  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Service Times
  • Help with WATTS Week!
  • Are You New?
    • Service Times
    • Directions & Parking
    • Accessibility
    • Child Care
    • Sunday School
    • Membership
  • About Us
    • Beliefs
    • History
      • Boyd Memorial Chapel
    • Affiliations
    • Baptism
    • Communion
    • Weddings
    • Request to Use the Facilities
    • Church Leadership
    • Staff
    • Employment
    • Facebook
  • Ministries
    • Children’s Ministry
      • CM News
      • Kids Sunday School
      • Child Care
      • Safe Sanctuaries
      • Sign up for the Weekly CM Email Blast
      • Vacation Bible School
    • Youth Ministry
    • Adult Christian Education
    • Weekday Preschool
    • Mission and Outreach
    • Rise Against Hunger
    • WATTS
    • Care and Compassion
    • Prayer
    • Music
      • Children’s Choirs
      • Youth Choir
    • Worship
      • Watch Worship Online
      • Worship and Discipleship Council Collaboration
      • New Stone Gathering
    • Congregational Life
    • Stewardship
      • Make a Pledge!
      • Questions and Answers About Pledging
      • Planned Gifting
      • Automatic Withdrawal
        • Printable Form
      • Frequently Asked Questions About Donating Online
      • Donate
  • News & Events
    • View Online Worship Services
    • Coronavirus
    • eNotice
    • Calendar
    • Subscribe to Weekly eNotices
    • Member Directory
  • Sermons
    • Dan McCoig
    • Amanda Thomas
  • Donate
  • WATCH WORSHIP
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / September 29, 2013 Sermon: “Making a Case for the Brothers”

September 29, 2013 Sermon: “Making a Case for the Brothers”

September 30, 2013 by Todd Bowman

September 29, 2013

“Making a Case for the Brothers”

The Rev. Maren Sonstegard-Spray

Genesis 37:12-24

12 Now his brothers went to pasture their father’s flock near Shechem.  13 And Israel said to Joseph, “Are not your brothers pasturing the flock at Shechem? Come, I will send you to them.” He answered, “Here I am.” 14 So he said to him, “Go now, see if it is well with your brothers and with the flock; and bring word back to me.” So he sent him from the valley of Hebron. He came to Shechem, 15 and a man found him wandering in the fields; the man asked him, “What are you seeking?” 16 “I am seeking my brothers,” he said; “tell me, please, where they are pasturing the flock.” 17 The man said, “They have gone away, for I heard them say, ‘Let us go to Dothan.’” So Joseph went after his brothers, and found them at Dothan. 18 They saw him from a distance, and before he came near to them, they conspired to kill him. 19 They said to one another, “Here comes this dreamer. 20 Come now, let us kill him and throw him into one of the pits; then we shall say that a wild animal has devoured him, and we shall see what will become of his dreams.” 21 But when Reuben heard it, he delivered him out of their hands, saying, “Let us not take his life.” 22 Reuben said to them, “Shed no blood; throw him into this pit here in the wilderness, but lay no hand on him”—that he might rescue him out of their hand and restore him to his father. 23 So when Joseph came to his brothers, they stripped him of his robe, the long robe with sleeves that he wore; 24 and they took him and threw him into a pit. The pit was empty; there was no water in it.

When best-selling authors Adele Faber and Elaine Mazlish were writing what was to be another best-selling book on parenting, “How to talk so kids will listen & listen so kids will talk,” they ran into a problem.  The chapter on sibling rivalry was getting out of hand – it was over a hundred pages long and they were only halfway through it.

Whenever they traveled around speaking about parenting the very mention of the words sibling rivalry would trigger an immediate and intense reaction.  Parents would say: “the fighting drives me up the wall,” “I don’t know what will happen first. Either they’ll kill each other or I’ll kill them.”

 

Take two or more kids in competition for their parents’ love and attention.  Add to that the envy that one child feels for the accomplishments of another, the resentment that each child feels for the privileges of the others, the personal frustrations that they don’t dare let out on anyone else but a brother or sister, and it is relational dynamite.

 

So the authors wrote an entire book just on parenting siblings, called “Siblings without Rivalry” and in it are chapters about comparing children, putting them in roles, showing preference for a child.

 

Many of us who grew up with siblings know exactly what all these things feel like.

 

When Faber and Mazlish gathered parents together to talk about their own challenges of parenting siblings, the most gut-wrenching stories were not about their children but their own experiences – always being told by a sister that they weren’t pretty, always feeling pressured to be the good child because an older sibling had a mental illness, becoming a workaholic because of always wanting to keep up with older siblings.  Story after story of anger and resentment because of favoritism and unfairness.

 

All things we see play out in the story of Joseph.

 

The text we read this morning drops us in the middle of the story where the anger of Joseph’s brothers is so great that they are ready to kill him, abandon him and sell him into slavery.

Here is how the story begins: “Joseph, being seventeen years old, was shepherding the flock with his brothers; he was a helper to the sons of Bilhah and Zilpah, his father’s wives; and Joseph brought a bad report of them to their father. Now Israel loved Joseph more than any other of his children, because he was the son of his old age; and he had made him a long robe with sleeves. But when his brothers saw that their father loved him more than all his brothers, they hated him, and could not speak peaceably to him. Once Joseph had a dream, and when he told it to his brothers, they hated him even more.”

 

Joseph has two dreams actually both involving all his brothers, even his mother and father, bowing down before him.  And those dreams made things worse.

 

I’m going to make a case for the brothers – if we were in their shoes, we might have felt the exact same way.  George Bush (not the president) wrote a classic commentary on Genesis and argued that grammatically that line about Joseph tending the flocks with his brothers should be taken to mean that he was the superintendent; he was the one in charge of the flocks and therefore of the brothers as well.  For that reason it would not be out of place for him to send back a report to his father about the activity of his brothers.

 

In addition Joseph had already been given the birthright from his father, meaning he was getting the wealth, power, privileges and prestige that came with it.  Reuben had lost it by sleeping with his father’s wife.  Joseph was the first born of the second wife, so although he wasn’t the next oldest he got the birthright.

Furthermore, Joseph was given this outward symbol of authority, or superior rank.  In this family there were twelve sons born of four different mothers but fairly close in age, all but Benjamin being born within a span of 6 or 7 years.

 

But Joseph was the youngest besides Benjamin, and he is seventeen when we pick up the story – a man in his culture as are all his older brothers but he is given authority other them.

 

His authority, his favor in his father’s eyes is marked for everyone to see with this coat that he is given.   The word that is used there in the Hebrew for the coat has been translated as a coat of many colors or a coat with sleeves, or an ornamental coat.  The only other place that word in used is in 2 Samuel where it describes the royal garment of King David’s daughter.

 

So it was a distinctive garment – an explicit sign that Joseph was the favorite. In the movie “A League of the Their Own” another story about sibling rivalry, the younger sister in the story, Kitt, is complaining about how her parents favor her older sister Dottie.  She says, “You ever hear Dad introduce us to people? “This is our daughter Dottie, and this is our other daughter, Dottie’s sister.” Should’ve just had you and bought a dog!”  So it was for Joseph’s brothers.

 

This pattern of showing favoritism, especially to a younger sibling, goes back generations: Abraham picking Isaac over Ishmael, Isaac favoring Esau but Rebekah picking Jacob, Jacob favoring the younger sister Rachel over the older sister Leah.

The opening line from the novel Anna Karenina is “Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.”  This is how this family has been unhappy for generations.

 

Add to all that the intensity of the dreams that Joseph, somewhat unwisely, shared with his family.  It is the dreams that the brothers mention as they create their plot to kill Joseph.  One commentator points out that the dreams were the tipping point, perhaps confirming their fears, that Joseph would ultimately be the powerful one in the family.  Fear so often breeds hatred

 

Miroslav Wolf in his book about hatred and forgiveness, “Exclusion and Embrace”, writes about how we exclude, we hate, because we are fearful of “anything that blurs our boundaries, disturbs our identities . . . Others strike us like objects that are ‘out of place,’ like ‘dirt’ that needs to be removed in order to return the sense of propriety to our world.”

 

And so the brothers hated Joseph and wanted to remove him.  He was a walking, dreaming, coat-wearing reminder of profound unfairness, of what happens when one sibling is loved too much, and the others too little.

 

Jeffery Kluger, a senior editor of science and technology at Time Magazine states that how we react to unfairness is “powerfully encoded in the human genome – we process that phenomenon through the same lobe in our brain the processes disgust meaning we react to the idea of being cheated the same way we react to putrefied meat.”

 

So you can imagine the feelings of the brothers as they see Joseph coming towards them as they pasture the herd, highly visible in his long sleeved coat, more than fifty miles from the security of his father’s house.  They decide to kill him and throw him into a pit, then they decide to just throw him into a pit to let him die, then they decide to sell him into slavery and make some money off the venture.  So it was that Joseph ends up in Egypt and on goes the story.

 

When I was in seminary one of the ways we were taught to approach a sermon was called the four pages, which meant there were four movements of the story to tell.  Here are the four movements: the problem in the text, the problem in the world, the grace in the text, the grace in the world.  Here is how this works for us with this story:

 

The problem in the text: We have a family aching under the burden of resentment, jealousy, fear, hatred, Siblings who hate each other because of favoritism shown by a parent.  But also siblings living with terrible guilt – later in Genesis as they are facing a grilling from Joseph who they do not recognize they say to each other, “Truly we are guilty concerning our brother, because we saw the distress of his soul when he pleaded with us, yet we would not listen; therefore this distress has come upon us”

 

The problem in the world: That most of us reading this passage have relationships stained by the very same things – old hurts that still fester, broken relationships, fear, hatred, perhaps we have not killed a sibling or sold them into slavery, but maybe we wanted to.  Maybe some of us are still fighting comparisons with a brother or sister or still feeling like mom or dad loved someone else best.

 

The grace in the text:  The grace in the text is something we have to wait for.  Theologian Søren Kierkegaard wrote “Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards.”  Such is Joseph’s story.  God is there all along but hidden, working in spite of the foolishness of Joseph or the misguided love of Jacob, or the anger of the brothers.  In the end Joseph’s placement in Egypt means the survival of his family, and not only survival but forgiveness and reconciliation with his brothers.

 

This is how the story ends (this is after Jacob has died):   “Realizing that their father was dead, Joseph’s brothers said, “What if Joseph still bears a grudge against us and pays us back in full for all the wrong that we did to him?” So they approached Joseph, saying, “Your father gave this instruction before he died, ‘Say to Joseph: I beg you, forgive the crime of your brothers and the wrong they did in harming you.’ Now therefore please forgive the crime of the servants of the God of your father.”

 

Joseph wept when they spoke to him. Then his brothers also wept, fell down before him, and said, “We are here as your slaves.”

 

But Joseph said to them, “Do not be afraid! Am I in the place of God?  Even though you intended to do harm to me, God intended it for good, in order to preserve a numerous people, as he is doing today.  So have no fear; I myself will provide for you and your little ones.” In this way he reassured them, speaking kindly to them.”

 

The grace in the world: Depending how deep the wrongs, it may be a long time for us as well to experience this kind of forgiveness or reconciliation.  We may not have lived far enough forward, to the see the grace in the rear view mirror.  But the promise of this text is that it is not impossible, it is not beyond hope.   And it is always the case, even when we don’t even speak God’s name, God is still there, bigger than our pettiness and blindness and fear.

 

Amen.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Serving Christ and Neighbor in the Heart of Winchester and Beyond

View Online Worship Services

Facebook Feed

Instagram Feed

firstpresbyterianwinchester

First Presbyterian Winchester
FPC Epiphany Seasonal Team Newsletter. Click the l FPC Epiphany Seasonal Team Newsletter. Click the link in the bio, then click "FPC News" button to locate the recent edition.
Worship at home with us this morning! Click the li Worship at home with us this morning! Click the link bio to go to our Facebook page, YouTube Channel, or our Virtual Church webpage for worship at 10 AM.
eNotice - Link in bio (FPC News) We're putting tog eNotice - Link in bio (FPC News) We're putting together care packages for our healthcare heroes! Have coffee with the pastors over Zoom this Sunday! and more! #winchesterva #pcusa
Whoo-hoo! Many friends were able to sign-up to hel Whoo-hoo! Many friends were able to sign-up to help with FPC's WATTS Week, but we still have some spots to fill out! In Guest Services, we need a few friends to assist on each day, and on the last day--Saturday, January 30. If you are able to volunteer, please sign-up wherever you can. Go over to http://ow.ly/Jd0w50D9PNO and take a look at each tab to see where help is needed. Instagramers, click link in bio. We do not have much time left before our assigned WATTS week. Please prayerfully consider how you can help if you are able. WATTS week is Saturday, January 23-Saturday morning, January 30. If you have signed up to donate supplies or food, come to the church parking lot for a drive-thru WATTS donation drop-off on Saturday, January 16 from 2pm-3pm, and Thursday, January 21 from 4pm-5pm. If you cannot make those dates, please contact the church office at info@fpcwinc.org. Drop-off via our kitchen door will also be available on Wednesday & Thursday, 1/20-21 from 10am-4pm.
Our Adult Faith Formation class begins tonight in Our Adult Faith Formation class begins tonight in 1/2 hr at 7:30pm.
Instagramers, click the link bio, we have the Zoom class link and class materials buttons in our Linktree.
OR...
To access the online class, click here: http://ow.ly/LE0K50D8TYJ
To access the class materials, click here: http://ow.ly/jfju50D8U1g

Led by Pastor Dan McCoig Jr. See you soon!
Special Announcements. Click in bio for latest FPC Special Announcements. Click in bio for latest FPC News.
(1) Adult Faith Formation MLK Jr Class Series begins TONIGHT at 7:30pm. Access via Zoom at https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89841223984
(2) WATTS needs YOU! You can donate money and/or supplies! We do need volunteers to assist in-person but we have safety protocols in place. Please read this email or go to fpcwinc.org/watts and click the Sign-Up Genius links for details on how to help and availability. WATTS hosted at ONE site this year at 308 N. Braddock Street. FPC's week to help is January 23-30.
(3) We are putting together care packages for our healthcare heroes! We are in need of donations and/or handwritten notes.
Read this special email for details and information.
Have you signed up yet to help with WATTS Week for Have you signed up yet to help with WATTS Week for FPC? This year will be a little different due to COVID-19. Go to https://www.fpcwinc.org/watts and click the Sign-Up Genius logo to be taken to the online sign-up forms. Please read each tab's description and details on how to help. If you need assistance, please send an email to info@fpcwinc.org for help.

Image description: The color purple background. In the color white, the WATTS logo with outstretched hands sheltering a person icon. Also in the color white, it reads: WATT Week for FPC is January 23-January 30. The entire season of WATTS will be permanently hosted at First UMC at 308 N. Braddock St. What is needed: dinner sponsorships, perishable and disposable dinnerware donations, and guest services helpers. Find Details on How to Help or Donate at fpcwinc.org/watts
#winchesterareatemporarythermalshelter  #winchesterva #pcusa
FPC Epiphany Seasonal Team Newsletter - Click link FPC Epiphany Seasonal Team Newsletter - Click link in bio, click first button (FPC news), then click the most recent link.
Worship at home with us this morning! Worship at home with us this morning!
This Week's eNotice - Online Holy Communion this S This Week's eNotice - Online Holy Communion this Sunday  Online Ordination and Installation of Ruling Elders Worship on Zoom this Sunday  Drive-Thru "Remembering Our Baptism" event in the church parking lot THIS Sunday afternoon  Sign-up for WATTS Week and more! Click link in bio, then click the first button to FPC's news, then click the recent link.
Screen readers: black and white simpe, line drawin Screen readers: black and white simpe, line drawing of a person baptizing another in a river, with a dove flying above. Text: January 10 is Baptism of the Lord Sunday, a day on which Christians commemorate Jesus’ baptism by John and remember their own baptisms. We invite you to a drive-through commemoration from 2:00 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. on January 10 in our Cameron Street parking lot [weather permitting]. Wooden hearts will be anointed with oil by Dan and Amanda and placed in persons outstretched hands using an extended reacher with the words “As God’s beloved, remember your baptism.” In response, you are asked to speak quietly or silently, “I remember my baptism and will show the love God has shown me to others. Amen.” ALL ARE WELCOME!
Screen Readers: Watercolor of the Holy Spirit as a Screen Readers: Watercolor of the Holy Spirit as a dove, over water, with pastel colors. 
Ordination and Installation of Ruling Elders of First Presbyterian Church of Winchester, Virginia, after our live-streamed worship on Sunday, January 10, 2021. 11:30 AM via Zoom. Access by click the link in bio and click the "Ordination" button.
This Sunday Only - Ordination/Installation Service This Sunday Only - Ordination/Installation Service and Drive-Thru event at FPC! Plus, sign-up to help, through donations or as a helper, for FPC's WATTS Week! Click the link in our bio, then click the first button view details of this email. Click the second button to sign-up for WATTS Week, whether through donations or as a helper.
Worship at home with us this morning! Click the li Worship at home with us this morning! Click the link in the bio, then click the live stream button.
HAPPY NEW YEAR! 2021!Click on the link, click on o HAPPY NEW YEAR! 2021!Click on the link, click on our linktree, click on the latest link!
Worship at home with us this morning! Click the li Worship at home with us this morning! Click the link in the bio, then click the live stream button.
MERRY CHRISTMAS! and it's Friday! eNotice is here! MERRY CHRISTMAS! and it's Friday! eNotice is here!🎄 Click the link in the bio, then the first button to see the latest eNotice. #winchesterva #pcusa #christmas #matthew25
Screen Readers: Click link in bio, then select the Screen Readers: Click link in bio, then select the second button "Pastor Dan's Christmas Letter" for the text. #winchesterva #christmas #christmaseve #pcusa
Screen readers: Join us for an illuminated, safe, Screen readers: Join us for an illuminated, safe, and outdoor Christmas Eve Service. Dress warmly--masks and distancing required. Bring a chair if needed. 5 pm (service will be brief). This service will occur regardless of the weather. If raining/snowing, cars are welcome in the parking lot (first come basis) and friends are welcome to stay in cars with windows down for sound. Luminaries and candles will be available. Our parking lot is located on South Cameron Street, near the intersection of Cork and Cameron Streets. #winchester #winchesterva #christmas #christmaseve #pcusa #worship
Join us virtually or in-person on Christmas Eve! W Join us virtually or in-person on Christmas Eve! We will premiere our virtual Lessons and Carols worship by noon, and you are welcome to join us in-person (masked and distanced) in our parking lot at 5 pm for a special worship service. This year's Christmas Eve offering will go to the Helper Fund. If you would like to make a donation online, go to our website, fpcwinc.org, and click "Donate". Online donors: be sure to designate your giving.
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Return to top

First Presbyterian Church of Winchester | 116 South Loudoun Street | Winchester, Virginia, USA, 22601

Tele. No.: 540-662-3824 | Fax: 540-662-8498